GENERAL ESSAY - GROUP 7 - Book Reviews
GROUP MEMBERS AND WORKS:
1. SEETHA LAKSHMI C - MODERNISM IN THE NOVELLA "METAMORPHOSIS" BY FRANZ KAFKA
2. SHALINI M - ECOFEMINISM IN ARUNDHATI ROY’S “THE GOD OF SMALL THINGS”
3. SHAMITHA S - "WOMEN AND NATURE: THE ROARING INSIDE HER" BY SUSAN GRIFFIN
4. SHARMILA M - "A THOUSAND ACRES" BY JANE SMILEY
5. SINDHU JA D- MODERNISM IN THE NOVEL "BELOVED" BY TONI MORRISON
ECOFEMINISM IN ARUNDHATI ROY’S “THE GOD OF SMALL THINGS”
ABSTRACT:
Ecofeminism is the movement in literature that focuses on the domination that ecology and women face in the hands of a male-centric world. It is said to be the branch of feminism and political ecology. Ecofeminists and ecofeminism work to bring out the relationship between nature and humans. This paper analyzes Arundhati Roy’s “The God of Small Things” as an ecofeminist text alongside Karen J warren’s “Introduction to Ecofeminism”.
KEYWORDS: ecofeminism, oppression, patriarchy, women, nature, exploitation, gender discrimination, environmental colonization.
Karen J Warren, the feminist philosopher, comments that environmental ethics should be feminist and feminist ethics should be ecological (Cuomo, Christine J). According to Warren, women and nature are indivisible and inseparable parts of the world, and in “Introduction to Ecofeminism”, she has provided the readers with connections between women and nature. She mentioned, “historical connections, conceptual connections, empirical and experiential connections, symbolic connections, epistemological connections, political connections, ethical connections, and theoretical connections” (Warren, Karen J). (2)
Ecofeminism is the view that describes the root cause of the environmental crisis, exploitation, ecological destruction, and women's oppression is capitalism and patriarchy. According to recent research and writings, it could be said that ecological concerns are crucial issues in the field of gender and green studies. Ecofeminism argues that women’s relationship with nature is ambivalent. Karen Warren defines Ecofeminism in her essay:
“Ecological feminism” is the name of a variety of different feminist perspectives the nature of the connections between the domination “Ecological feminist philosophy” is the name of a diversity of philosophical approaches to the variety of different connections between feminism and the environment. (Warren, Karen J) (7)
Arundhati Roy in her novel “The God of Small Things” discuss on feminism, ecology, spirituality, loss of identity, exploitation and accommodation that the people are confronted in the society (8). Roy starts the novel by describing the environment which she used in her novel, Ayemenem. Ayemenem is a real green town, set near Meenachal river, and Roy’s novel introduction flourishes the richness of the nature in which she was born. She comments that,
“May in Ayemenem is hot brooding month. The days are long and humid. The river shrinks and black crows gorge on the bright the mangoes in still, dust green trees. Red bananas ripen. Jackfruits burst. Dissolute blue bottles hum vacuously in the fruity air. Then they stun themselves against clear windowpanes and die, fatly baffled by the sun…… But by the early June the south-west monsoon breaks and there are three months of wind and water….” (The God of Small Things, 1) (1)
Roy shows how the non-human elements co-habit with the human. She talks about how the ripened banana, busted jackfruit, moss wall, moths, insects, rivers, ponds coincide with each other. Once she finished the description of the environment, she explains the ecological concerns which she cannot shake from her mind. Roy employes the concept of ecofeminism in her novel, but introducing Ammu and her twins, and the nature that is being destroyed by the villagers in order to make it modernize.
“The God of Small Things” is considered an ecofeminist novel as it mourns for the women and the nature which are exploited as a result of patriarchy and capitalism. The very first chapter of the novel, ‘Paradise, Pickles & Preserves” revolves around the grandmother of the story, Mammachi, who runs the pickle factory after the death of her husband. This chapter talks about how the marginalized women are exploited in private sectors as they below to the lower caste, hence Untouchables.
In the beginning of the novel Roy talks about the beauty of nature but gradually, Roy talks about how the river in the town was overused and contaminated. Roy comments that, a long time ago, Ayemenem’s river was popular because of its clean, unpolluted water that streams for the entire surrounding. She talks about the freshness, greenery that made the people of the town connected with nature. But the town gradually started to civilize and urbanize. The bond between the nature and women are shown throughout the novel. One such event is when Chacko, uncle of the twins, explains the history lesson to them. While teaching the twins Chacko refers to nature as “Earth Woman”.
“...he told them about the Earth Woman. He made them imagine that the earth -four thousand six hundred million years old - was a forty-six-year-old woman…. It had taken the whole of Earth Woman's life for the earth to become what it was.” (The God of Small Things,53-54). (1)
The rivers are known as the life supporters as they play a very crucial role in civilization. Also, these rivers can be equated to women as they are expected to nurture the people and they are often exploited to the human’s use. Similarly, the river and Ammu can be equated in this novel. The Meenachal river is the source of livelihood for the people in and around the town as it is the main source for the fishermen’s income. But Roy shows, though it is calm, during rain, it turnsinto into into a monster and swallows everything that is in the riverside and becomes a destroyer. Likewise, Ammu, though she remains calm and portrays a straight face, she could be seen as a sleeping volcano, who would erupt once triggered by earthquake.
Women and Nature are considered as mediocre for men (8). This could be depicted through the grandfather of the twins, Pappachi and Chacko. Gender discrimination could be seen through these characters. Mammachi was not treated equally in the family which reflected towards Ammu. Mammachi, too, never treated her son and her daughter on par. Though Mammachi practiced gender discrimination, she, too, was an unfortunate woman and wife. She was never treated with respect by the male of the house. She suffered, tortured, physically and psychologically abused by the patriarchy. Still, we could see that she gives importance to patriarchal society and its norms.
“Women have been always man’s dependent, if not slaves; the two sexes have never shared the world of equality” (Beauvoir, Simone de - The second sex) (9)
The novel, which in non-linear in form, continuously and simultaneously shows how the women and nature are exploited by men. Through Estha’s walk around Ayemenem in his twenties, Roy shows the aftermath of Globalization - exploitation. Estha recognizes how the town has changed recklessly alongside the loss of people’s innocence and love towards nature. Estha also notes that the river which was once clean and unpolluted is now just a, “a slow, slugging green ribbon lawn that ferried garbage to sea” (Roy, Arundhati).
The novel depicts the environmental colonization (8) towards the farming Indian landscape by Pappachi and Kochamma. Kerala, during the British colony started coffee, tea and rubber plantation. Since Pappachi is an entamologist, he estranged Indian environment. Kochamma’s gardening techniques show her attitude of exploitation and abuse over the non-human world.
Through the novel, it is clear that though before few centuries both women and nature were worshiped but as the time passed and men had an upper hand in the society throw capitalism and patriarchy, it is evident that women and nature became an object in the lenses of men as the exploited and abuses both of them. This could be supported through Warren’s comment:
“Prior to the seventeenth century, nature was conceived on as an organic model as a benevolent female, a nurturing mother; after the scientific revolution, nature was conceived on a mechanistic model as a (mere) machine, inert, dead. On both models, nature was female.” (9)
To conclude, the significance of women and nature connectedness, their crucial role in the ecosystem and in society by accepting the challenge that society imposed on them shows that the novel, “The God of Small Things” is an ecofeminist novel. Roy as an ecofeminist, voiced the subjugated women and nature in her novel and portrayed how women became rebellious in the novel and the awareness of nature's domination. As Warren believes, women and nature are connected and oppressed and subordinated by the society which thinks that both are existing for human needs.
WORKS CITED:
1. Roy, Arundhati. The God of Small Things: Booker Prize Winner 1997. Penguin Books, 2002.
2. Warren, Karen J. “Warren's Introduction to Ecofeminism – There It Is . org.”ThereItIs.org,21January2014,Https://thereitis.org/warrens-introduction-to-ecofeminism/. Accessed 18 November 2022.
3. Warren, Karen J. “The Power and Promise of Ecological Feminism.” rintintin.colorado.edu,
https://rintintin.colorado.edu/~vancecd/phil308/WarrenK.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2022.
4. Stange, Mary. “ECOFEMINISM: A STUDY ON INDIAN WOMEN'S DEDICATION
TOWARDS THE ENVIRONMENT.” Anu Books, https://anubooks.com/wp-content/uploads
/2017/04/RJPSSs-2014-No.-1-3.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2022.
5. Rao, Manisha, et al. Ecofeminism at the Crossroads in India: A Review, https://www.unive.it
/pag/fileadmin/user_upload/dipartimenti/DSLCC/documenti/DEP/numeri/n20/13_20_-Rao_
Ecofeminism.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2022.
6. “Postcolonial ecofeminism in Arundhati Roy's The God of Small Things.” UNCG,16February2016,
https://libres.uncg.edu/ir/uncp/f/Postcolonial%20Ecofeminism%20in%20Arundhati%20Roy%20s%20The
%20God%20of%20Small%20Things.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2022.
7. Home.”YouTube, http://www.vedegylet.hu./Warren-Ecofeminism.Overview. Accessed 18 November 2022.
8. CONCEPT OF ECOCRITICISM IN ROY'S THE GOD OF SMALL THINGS.”AdalyaJournal,
https://adalyajournal.com/gallery/53-sep-1770.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2022.
9. An Ecofeminist Reading of Arundhathi Roy's The God of Small Things.”
Academia.edu,https://www.academia.edu/33800567/An_Ecofeminist_Reading_of_Arundhathi_Roy_s_
The_God_of_Small_Things. Accessed 18 November 2022.
Women and Nature by Susan Griffin is a book that explores the relationship between women and nature. The book is a collection of essays that examine the historical, cultural, and philosophical factors that have shaped this relationship. Griffin argues that the exploitation of nature and the subjugation of women are linked and that both issues must be addressed in order to achieve a more equitable and sustainable future. Overview: The Women and Nature book is divided into two parts. The first part examines the historical and cultural factors that have shaped the relationship between women and nature. The second part explores the philosophical and psychological dimensions of this relationship.
Part One: In the first part of the book, Griffin examines the ways in which women have been connected to nature throughout history. She traces the roots of this connection back to ancient myths and religious traditions, which often portrayed women as the guardians and protectors of nature. However, she also notes that this connection has been exploited and used to justify the subjugation of women. Griffin then goes on to explore the impact of the Enlightenment on the relationship between women and nature. She argues that the Enlightenment promoted a dualistic worldview that separated humans from nature and created a hierarchy in which men were seen as superior to women and nature was seen as inferior to human civilization. Finally, Griffin examines the ways in which industrialization and capitalism have further exacerbated the exploitation of nature and the subjugation of women. She argues that the dominant economic system is based on the idea of unlimited growth and consumption, which is unsustainable and ultimately destructive. Part Two: In the second part of the book, Griffin explores the philosophical and psychological dimensions of the relationship between women and nature. She argues that the dominance of nature and the subjugation of women are both rooted in a desire for control and power. She suggests that this desire is ultimately a product of a patriarchal culture that values dominance and control over cooperation and collaboration. Griffin also examines the role of language in shaping our relationship with nature. She suggests that language is not just a tool for communication, but also a means of creating and reinforcing social norms and values. She argues that the language we use to describe nature often reflects and reinforces our belief in our superiority over it. Finally, Griffin explores the ways in which women can reclaim their connection to nature and use it as a source of empowerment. She suggests that women can challenge the dominant culture by developing a more collaborative and cooperative relationship with nature. She argues that this can lead to a more sustainable and equitable future for all.
Evaluation: Women and Nature is a powerful and thought-provoking book that offers a compelling analysis of the relationship between women and nature. Griffin's writing is clear and engaging, and her arguments are well-supported by historical and cultural examples. The book is a valuable resource for anyone interested in feminist theory, environmental studies, or social justice. One of the strengths of the book is its interdisciplinary approach. Griffin draws on a wide range of sources, including literature, philosophy, and anthropology, to build her argument. This interdisciplinary approach allows her to explore the relationship between women and nature from a variety of angles, and to show how different factors have contributed to the current state of affairs.Another strength of the book is its emphasis on the need for action. Griffin does not just diagnose the problem, she also offers concrete suggestions for how to address it. Her emphasis on collaboration and cooperation as a means of challenging the dominant culture is particularly compelling, and offers a hopeful vision for the future. However, one potential weakness of the book is its focus on Western culture. While Griffin acknowledges that the exploitation of nature and the subjugation of women are global issues, her analysis is primarily focused on the West. This could limit the applicability of her arguments to other cultural contexts. Conclusion: In conclusion, Women and Nature is a foundational work in ecofeminist theory, and has had a significant impact on the development of this field. One of its major contributions is its identification of the interconnectedness between gender oppression and environmental degradation. Hence, by highlighting the ways in which these two issues are intertwined, Griffin helped to create a new framework for understanding both environmentalism and feminism.
A THOUSAND ACRES BY JANE SMILEY
- SHARMILA M (2113312005036)
Title: "A Thousand Acres”
Author: Jane Smiley
Originally published: October 23, 1991
Genre: Domestic Realism
ISBN: 0-394-57773-6
Length: 367
A Thousand Acres is a Pulitzer Prize-winning adaptation of King Lear that takes place in the 1970s on an Iowa farm. It's a brilliantly written account of the sudden and total collapse of one family. The majority of the time, I really like it, but near the conclusion, the characters, especially the narrator, made me eager for it to be over.
Novelist Jane Smiley was born in the United States on September 26, 1949. For her 1991 book Thousand Acres, she was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction.
Smiley graduated from Community School and John Burroughs School. She was born in Los Angeles, California, and raised in the St. Louis neighborhood of Webster Groves, Missouri. She graduated with a BA in literature from Vassar College in 1971 before earning an MA, MFA, and PhD from the University of Iowa in 1975, 1976, and 1978, respectively. She studied in Iceland for a year as a Fulbright Scholar while pursuing her doctorate. She taught undergraduate and graduate creative writing workshops as an English professor at Iowa State University from 1981 until 1996.
A haughty and prosperous farmer named Larry Cook serves as the book's King Lear. His daughters are Caroline, Rose, and the narrator Ginny. The farm is doing well, the daughters and their families appear to get along, and despite Larry being a rigid tyrant, most people have settled into a pattern that minimizes the conflict with him. On the surface, everything appears to be well with the family.
When Larry plans to incorporate the 1,000-acre farm and distribute authority among his three daughters, everything starts to fall apart. The appearance of former neighbor Jess Clark, who plays Edmund from King Lear, coincides with this occasion. The two incidents caused the family's dissolution. The family cannot handle the adultery, madness, greed, treachery, and memories of abuse that follow.
This, in my opinion, was a great way to update King Lear for the twenty-first century. The setting on a farm makes sense given that a thousand acres of outstanding farmland in Iowa are similar to their own tiny kingdom. And Larry Cook ruled his realm with a despotic hand. Larry lacks any empathy, which I believe to be a flaw, in contrast to King Lear, who I seem to have had some pity for. I wasn't really concerned with his fate.
The way the events unfolded was interesting. I thought Larry's decision regarding the farm and his family's ensuing breakdown happened very quickly. Ginny, for instance, goes from remarking about her husband Ty, "the fact was that even after seventeen years of marriage, I was still pleased to see him every time he appeared," to unrepentantly cheating on him a few months later. The implosion's rapidity, in my opinion, shows that everything was only a house of cards constructed on fragile ground. Otherwise, I didn't really understand it
A rotting onion's layers are peeled back slowly by the author as she unveils the magnitude of Ginny and Rose's deceit. At initially bland and mild-mannered, Ginny gradually develops into a murderous killer. Additionally, Rose is shown as a sympathetic breast cancer sufferer before gradually revealing herself to be a cunning manipulator. I didn't think the two could be capable of perfidy on the level of Shakespeare at the start of the book, but by the end they would have done Shakespeare proud.
In addition to the brilliant plot and deft character development, Smiley writes in some really gorgeous passages when describing the Iowa landscape.
I occasionally had the impression that I was learning about farming from a poet because the descriptions are both poetic and educational.
Overall, I would absolutely suggest A Thousand Acres, but be ready to hate most of the characters by the conclusion of the book and perhaps even wish for their deaths.
Comments
Post a Comment